The Challenge
Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) face mounting societal and economic pressures to leverage artificial intelligence for enhanced mission delivery, yet they encounter distinct operational constraints such as tight budgets and mission-centric rather than technology-driven cultures. While private sector AI adoption is heavily researched, empirical evidence and systematic synthesis regarding how mission-driven organizations integrate AI remain fragmented, unevenly distributed, and heavily biased toward larger entities. This systematic review addresses the critical gap in understanding how diverse NGOs navigate the tensions between promised technological efficiencies and practical organizational limitations across varying sizes and geographic contexts.
Core Findings
Utilizing the PRISMA 2020 protocol and the SPIDER framework, the authors conducted a systematic literature review of English-language empirical studies, case studies, and technical reports published between 2020 and 2025, yielding a final corpus of 65 studies. Grounded theoretically in the Technology-Organization-Environment (TOE) framework and Rogers' Diffusion of Innovations (DOI) theory, the study adopts a narrative and thematic synthesis approach. The review identifies six primary AI use case categories in the non-profit sector: Engagement, Creativity, Decision-Making, Prediction, Management, and Optimization. Furthermore, it surfaces critical challenges and proposed solutions across technological, organizational, and environmental contexts, demonstrating that AI adoption remains heavily skewed toward larger, better-resourced organizations.
Strategic Takeaway
This systematic review provides organizational leaders and digital transformation scholars with a rigorous roadmap for understanding technology assimilation in resource-constrained environments. By mapping AI use cases and adoption barriers through the Technology-Organization-Environment (TOE) framework, the research illustrates how structural inequalities—such as organization size and geographic disparities—dictate digital maturity in the non-profit sector. For digital leadership practice, the findings emphasize that overcoming technological hurdles requires aligning AI initiatives with mission-centric cultures, navigating complex donor expectations, and developing strategic governance models tailored to the unique economic realities of civil society organizations.