Towards Interactive Evaluations for Interaction Harms in Human-AI Systems

Source: Peer-Reviewed Scholarly Research

The Challenge

Current artificial intelligence evaluation frameworks rely predominantly on static, single-turn prompts that fail to capture complex interaction harms developing over sustained human-AI relationships. As generative AI systems increasingly act as conversational companions and cognitive assistants, traditional output-based safety checks miss critical cumulative issues such as social manipulation, inappropriate parasocial dependencies, and cognitive overreliance. This evaluation mismatch creates substantial governance and ethical blind spots for organizations and regulators deploying interactive technologies.

Core Findings

The paper critically analyzes the shortcomings of contemporary AI evaluations, identifying three primary weaknesses: their static nature, the flawed assumption of a universal user experience, and limited construct validity. Drawing insights from human-computer interaction (HCI), natural language processing, and the social sciences, the authors advocate for an interactional ethics paradigm shift. They outline practical principles for designing interactive evaluations that incorporate ecologically valid interaction scenarios, multidimensional human impact metrics, and varied participation approaches to assess temporal, cumulative dynamics in human-AI systems.

Strategic Takeaway

For organizational leaders and digital strategists, this research highlights the danger of relying on static vendor benchmarks when deploying enterprise or customer-facing AI agents. Digital leadership requires moving beyond isolated output testing toward longitudinal socio-technical monitoring. Organizations must evaluate how sustained AI engagement alters workforce decision-making, cognitive autonomy, and relational dependencies. Integrating interactive evaluation frameworks into governance protocols ensures that AI adoption enhances human capability rather than inducing unintended psychological or operational vulnerabilities over time.

Deep Dive Q&A

Why are static, single-turn AI evaluations insufficient?

Static evaluations test individual prompts in isolation, missing cumulative interaction harms—such as cognitive overreliance, manipulation, and inappropriate dependencies—that only emerge over sustained multi-turn human-AI conversations.

What is the proposed alternative evaluation paradigm?

The authors propose an interactional ethics framework grounded in human-computer interaction and social sciences, utilizing ecologically valid interaction scenarios, human impact metrics, and varied participation approaches.

How does this research impact organizational AI deployment?

It urges leaders to adopt longitudinal governance strategies that monitor how continuous employee or customer engagement with AI systems gradually shapes behavior, decision-making, and organizational trust.

Related Research & Implementation Playbooks

Cross-disciplinary frameworks and practical blueprints connected to this insight.